New emergency care guidelines include
dramatic changes to cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and emphasis
on chest compressions, according to authors of the 2005 American
Heart Association Guidelines for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation
and Emergency Cardiovascular Care.
The guidelines were published online
today in Circulation: Journal of the American Heart Association.
They provide recommendations for how lay rescuers and emergency
healthcare providers should resuscitate victims of cardiovascular
emergencies. Topics include CPR, the use of automated external
defibrillators (AEDs) and recommendations for advanced cardiovascular
life support (ACLS) and pediatric advanced life support (PALS).
The 2005 guidelines emphasize that
high-quality CPR, particularly effective chest compressions, contributes
significantly to the successful resuscitation of cardiac arrest
patients. Studies show that effective chest compressions create
more blood flow through the heart to the rest of the body, buying
a few minutes until defibrillation can be attempted or the heart
can pump blood on its own. The guidelines recommend that rescuers
minimize interruptions to chest compressions and suggest that
rescuers “push hard and push fast” when giving chest
compressions.
“The 2005 guidelines take a
‘back to basics’ approach to resuscitation,”
said Robert Hickey, M.D., chair of the American Heart Association’s
Emergency Cardiovascular Care programs. “Since the 2000
guidelines, research has strengthened our emphasis on effective
CPR as a critically important step in helping save lives. CPR
is easy to learn and do, and the association believes the new
guidelines will contribute to more people doing CPR effectively.”
The most significant change to CPR
is to the ratio of chest compressions to rescue breaths –
from 15 compressions for every two rescue breaths in the 2000
guidelines to 30 compressions for every two rescue breaths in
the 2005 guidelines. The 30-to-two ratio is the same for CPR that
a single lay rescuer provides to adults, children and infants
(excluding
newborns). The change resulted from studies showing that blood
circulation increases with each chest compression in a series
and must be built back up after interruptions. The only exception
to the new ratio is when two healthcare providers give CPR to
a child or infant (except newborns), in which case they should
provide 15 compressions for every two rescue breaths.
Another guidelines change emphasizing
the importance of CPR is the sequence of rhythm analysis and CPR
when using AEDs. Previously, when AED pads were applied to the
chest, the device analyzed the heart rhythm, delivered a shock
if necessary, and analyzed the heart rhythm again to determine
whether the shock successfully stopped the abnormal rhythm. The
cycle of analysis, shock and re-analysis could be repeated three
times before CPR was recommended, resulting in delays of 37 seconds
or more. Now, after one shock, the new guidelines recommend that
rescuers provide about two minutes of CPR, beginning with chest
compressions, before activating the AED to re-analyze the heart
rhythm and attempt another shock. Studies have shown that the
first AED shock stops the abnormal cardiac arrest rhythm more
than 85 percent of the time and that a brief period of chest compressions
between shocks can deliver oxygen to the heart, increasing the
likelihood of successful defibrillation. The guidelines also recommend
that healthcare providers minimize interruptions to chest compressions
by doing heart rhythm checks, inserting airway devices, and administering
of drugs without delaying CPR.
The new recommendations continue to
encourage greater implementation of AED programs in public locations
like airports, casinos, sports facilities and businesses. The
2005 guidelines reflect results of the Public Access Defibrillation
trial, which reinforced the importance of planned and practiced
response to cardiac emergencies by lay rescuers. The new guidelines
recommend that 911 dispatchers be trained to provide CPR instructions
by phone and help callers correctly identify cardiac arrest victims.
Dispatchers may walk rescuers through compressions-only CPR for
most adult victims of cardiac arrest; however, instructions to
do compressions and rescue breaths will be given for infants and
children or adult victims of asphyxia, caused by near-drowning
or other non-cardiac causes. Dispatchers also should be trained
to recognize the symptoms of heart attack and other Acute Coronary
Syndromes, and advise such patients to chew an aspirin while awaiting
EMS.
To increase successful resuscitation,
new guidelines advise EMS systems to evaluate their current protocols,
shorten the response time for cardiac arrest patients, then document
the impact of such changes on the number of lives saved.
The guidelines are based on the Consensus
on Science and Treatment Recommendations (CoSTR), a.document developed
by the International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation. This
group includes the American Heart Association and leading international
resuscitation councils. The review of resuscitation literature
reflected in CoSTR is the largest ever published. It took more
than 36 months and includes input from 380 international experts
CoSTR serves as the scientific basis for many countries’
resuscitation treatment guidelines.
| 2005 Recommendation |
2000 Recommendation |
Explanation |
Basic Life Support |
Increased emphasis on delivery of effective
chest compressions |
Emphasized the first three links in the
Chain of Survival: early access, early CPR, and early defibrillation.
Stated early CPR significantly improved survival. Named
early defibrillation as the single greatest determinant
of survival for adult victims of cardiac arrest. |
When chest compressions are interrupted,
blood flow stops. Limiting interruptions to chest compressions
will result in greater survival.
In any given series (cycle) of chest compressions, earlier
compressions are less effective than later ones. Therefore,
fewer interruptions increase the percentage of effective
chest compressions.
Allowing the chest wall to fully “recoil” or
return to its normal position between compressions results
in better re-filling of blood in the heart, which allows
more blood to be pumped to the rest of the body during the
next compression. |
Single CPR compression-to-ventilation ratio:
30:2 for all rescuers responding alone to victims of any
age, except newborns.
CPR for newborns is the same as 2000 guidelines recommendation. |
A compression to ventilation ratio of 15
to 2 was recommended for adult CPR; a ratio of 5 to 1 for
child and infant CPR.
Three compressions for every one breath should be given
to newborns, totaling 90 compressions and 30 breaths per
minute. |
A single ratio will make learning the correct
procedure for responding to victims of all ages easier and
increase the likelihood that a rescuer will remember the
steps of CPR during an emergency.
The new ratio also helps reduce interruptions in chest
compressions (see explanation above). |
AED programs should be implemented in public
locations where there’s a relatively high likelihood
of witnessed cardiac arrest (eg, airports, casinos, sports
facilities and businesses). |
Key elements of successful AED programs
were recommended, including healthcare provider oversight,
training of likely rescuers, link to local EMS system and
process of continuous quality improvement. |
Some AEDs do not require a medical prescription,
so healthcare provider oversight of AED programs is not
mandatory.
The Public Access Defibrillation trial reinforced the
importance of planned and practiced response. Lay rescuer
programs in airports and casinos and by police officers
have reported survival rates as high as 49 percent to 74
percent when responding to sudden cardiac arrest caused
by ventricular fibrillation. |
A single shock from a defibrillator, followed
by immediate CPR for two minutes, beginning with chest compressions,
should be used to treat cardiac arrest caused by ventricular
fibrillation (VF-the abnormal heart rhythm responsible for
most cardiac arrests). |
Up to three shocks in a series were recommended
to treat cardiac arrest with a “shockable” rhythm
before returning to chest compressions; the heart rhythm
was evaluated before and after each shock. |
Repeated cycles of rhythm analysis and shock
result in delays of up to 37 or more seconds before the
first post-shock chest compressions are delivered. Most
defibrillators eliminate VF more than 85 percent of the
time. If the first shock fails, immediate CPR (before trying
another shock) is likely to contribute to the success of
a subsequent shock. Even when a shock eliminates VF, it
may take several minutes for the heart to pump blood effectively,
even if a normal heart rhythm returns. A brief period of
chest compressions can deliver oxygen to the heart during
this post-shock period, increasing the likelihood that the
heart will begin to effectively pump blood on its own. |
After giving two rescue breaths, lay rescuers
no longer check for signs of circulation before beginning
chest compressions. |
After giving two rescuer breaths, lay rescuers
were instructed to check for signs of circulation (normal
breathing, coughing or movement). Lay rescuers gave rescue
breathing without chest compressions to victims with signs
of circulation who were not breathing normally. |
Lay providers cannot reliably detect the
presence of circulation in a victim. Great harm can be done
when rescuers don’t do chest compressions when they’re
needed. Relatively minimal harm can be done by providing
chest compressions when they aren’t needed. Therefore,
the new guidelines do not recommend that lay rescuers look
for “signs of circulation” before delivering
chest compressions. This eliminates the chance that lay
rescuers might not recognize true cardiac arrest, and reduces
delays to chest compressions. Eliminating instructions to
look for signs of circulation and for delivering “rescue
breathing without chest compressions” reduces the
number of skills required for lay rescuers. This makes it
more likely that the lay provider will learn and remember
the steps of CPR. |
Dispatchers should be trained to recognize
the symptoms of Acute Coronary Syndromes (ACS), and advise
patients with symptoms of ACS without history of aspirin
allergy or gastrointestinal bleeding to chew 160 mg –
325 mg of aspirin while awaiting the arrival of EMS providers. |
Dispatchers were not instructed to recognize
ACS or recommend aspirin. |
Early administration of aspirin has been
associated with decreased mortality rates in several clinical
trials. Many studies have demonstrated the safety of aspirin
administration. |
| 2005 Recommendation |
2000 Recommendation |
Explanation |
Advanced Life
Support |
Basic Life Support (BLS) skills are the
priority in treating cardiac arrest. Providers must minimize
interruptions to chest compressions. |
Heart rhythm analysis, delivery of shocks
and selection of drug therapies resulted in frequent interruptions
to CPR. |
Studies show that providing continuous CPR
outweighs the potential effects of drug therapies, so interruptions
should be minimized. |
New neurological tests and evaluations given
24 hours and 72 hours after resuscitation can predict survival
to hospital discharge. |
No specific neurologic signs indicated the
potential for successful resuscitation. |
New research suggests there are specific
clinical signs, such as certain brain responses to stimuli,
that correlate strongly with death or poor brain function
following resuscitative efforts. More research is needed
to predict potential for survival during resuscitation. |
Unconscious adult patients with return of
spontaneous circulation after out-of-hospital cardiac arrest
should be cooled for 12 to 24 hours to 32 degrees C - 34
degrees C when the initial rhythm was ventricular fibrillation.
Similar therapy may be beneficial for patients with non-VF
arrest out of hospital or for in-hospital arrest. |
Mild hypothermia may be beneficial….but
hypothermia should not be induced actively after resuscitation
from cardiac arrest. (Position was updated in a 2003 science
statement from the International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation,
which supported induced hypothermia following resuscitation.) |
In two randomized clinical trials, induced
hypothermia (cooling within minutes to hours after the return
of spontaneous circulation) resulted in improved survival
and brain function in adults who remained comatose after
initial resuscitation from out of hospital VF cardiac arrest. |
Tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) is recommended
for carefully selected patients with acute ischemic stroke,
but cautions that tPA must be administered in the setting
of a clearly defined protocol and institutional commitment. |
Administration of tPA was recommended for
carefully selected patients with acute ischemic stroke if
they had no contraindications to fibrinolytic therapy and
if the drug can be administered within 3 hours of the onset
of stroke symptoms |
National Institute of Neurological Disorders
and Stroke (NINDS) results have been supported by subsequent
one year follow up, reanalysis of the NINDS data and a meta
analysis. Additional trials supported the NINDS results.
Note: Higher complications of hemorrhage following tPA was
reported in one study when participating hospitals did not
require strict adherence to NINDS protocols. |